Monday Musings – Could You Spare Some Change?

It was cold outside.  That was to be expected though, as it was well past 7:00 pm.  The parking lot was rather full considering the amount of rain coming down.  I parked several feet from the front of the store and grabbed my bag as I slammed the car door shut.  I ducked my head to avoid the rain that was falling mercilessly on my unprotected shoulders.  It didn’t do any good, but I couldn’t stop myself.  

Suddenly she was right in front of me.  She was so quiet that I hadn’t heard her.  She was mumbling something as she walked up to me.  I recoiled and began backing away, desperate to get in the store where it was “safe.”  Her sudden appearance had taken me by surprise me and left me speechless.  I stammered something incoherent and skirted around her.  Then I made my way into the store without looking back.

But I couldn’t shake her image out of my head.  What did she want from me?  Should I have stopped and talked to her?  What if she needed help?  My first reaction had been fear.  I realize I have an over-active imagination, but I wondered if it was a scam and I was to be the unwitting victim.  But then I wondered if maybe she was hurt or stranded and needed help.  

These thoughts continued as I made my way through the store.  I wasn’t there long, maybe 15 minutes, but when I returned to the parking lot, I was prepared.  She was right where I left her.  Warily, I approached her.

“What do you need?” I asked.

An inaudible sentence was spoken in my direction.

“I’m sorry, I can’t hear you.  Did you need something?” I asked again, as I cautiously stepped closer.

“I need some money for food,” was her reply.

I realized right then that I had a choice.  I was two feet from my car and it would have been easy to get in and drive off.  I didn’t remember having any bills in my wallet and I told her so.  But I couldn’t leave her there, in the drizzling, cold rain.

“Can I buy you something to eat?” I asked.

“Yes, I’ve eaten at that place before,” she said, as she pointed to the burrito place behind me.  ”A taco, I think it was.”

“Would you like me to get you some food, another taco perhaps?  Will you stay here and not leave?”

“Yes, that would be good.”

I returned a few minutes later with food and drink in hand.  She was talking to a man who had rolled down his window to give her some money.  Then she turned around and shuffled in my direction, hands outstretched.  

“Thank you ma’am,” she said.  ”And God bless you.”

I got in my car and buckled the seatbelt.  She began to walk away, head turned down, chin tucked in against the cold.  I started the engine and let it idle as I watched her move.  Then I put the car in drive and eased out of the parking space.  By the time I had gotten to the end of the row, she was gone.

**************************

I’ve had a hard time putting this experience out of my mind.   I think I’ve continued to think about it because I don’t know how to handle these situations.  According to my Christian beliefs, I should be like the Good Samaritan and help those who are in need.  It should be an automatic response to assist them in whatever way I can.  The reality, however, is often quite different.  

Walking to and from work on the busy streets of the District, I often see panhandlers and homeless people sitting on the sidewalk, asking for change.  Day and in and day out, the same people sitting in the same spots.  I’ve even gotten yelled at for not acknowledging their pleas when I was in a hurry or had my hands full.  So I have become somewhat jaded and find myself quickly averting my eyes when someone approaches me. 

It hasn’t always been this way though.  There was a time when I wasn’t so desensitized to the struggles of the people around me.  There was a time when I wasn’t so frightened to help those people.  I think I’ve heard one too many stories of someone being taken advantage of or being in the wrong place at the wrong time.  I’ve lived in the city too long, I guess.  When someone approaches me, especially in dimly lit surroundings, my instinct is to run. 

So what do I do?  Do I take a chance and offer some support?  Do I throw caution and fear to the wind?  Or, another question, am I really helping them by giving them money or am I merely perpetuating the problem?

What do you do when faced with such a situation?

Share/Save/Bookmark

The Wife of Odie - January 12, 2009 - 6:55 am

That’s such a hard call. I think your gut instinct will help you to know what to do in any given situation. I like to help out, but it’s almost impossible to give money or food to EVERY homeless person I see on any given day. I used to try to have snacks on me so I could give those out instead of money. And I love that we can give tithes to the church and they will help distribute the money. It’s so heartbreaking though to see those in need.

Katy - January 12, 2009 - 7:15 am

Hi!

I’m mostly a lurker on your site, but I just had to comment because I run into this too. I live in Chicago. Like Wife of Odie, I also try to have whole fruit or other snacks in my bag that I can give to people. I also made up a little pocket-sized list of shelters, churches, soup kitchens, and homeless support offices in Chicago that I give to people too. I just keep a little stack of them in my purse. Sometimes they can’t always read, sadly, but it’s helpful for some people. I saw someone distributing something like it on the streets in Houston once, and I thought it was such a good idea that I made my own for Chicago!

Margie - January 12, 2009 - 7:37 am

Oh, girl, that is a tough one. It is always wise to be as careful as possible and you can’t help everyone you make contact with. In the town I live, there are many shelters and places for the homeless to have meals and/or a place to stay. If there is such where you are, donate either your time or money to them as your way of helping. But I think you did the right thing in this particular instance. You didn’t put yourself in harm’s way and now your conscience is clear too. Have a great day.

kikibibi - January 12, 2009 - 8:26 am

You have to help. We have to help. If you can’t help right when the opportunity presents itself (for example, if she hadn’t been there when you came out of the store), help in other ways. Sign up to work in the soup kitchen (just take an extra long lunch break from work), make an extra lasagna or casserole and stick it in the freezer, to deliver to a shelter in the future – they always need extra food. Send money! Attend a fund raiser! Pray. There are so many ways we can attempt to follow the example of Jesus, and care for and love everyone around us. Never let that image of the woman in the rain leave your mind and heart.
Peace, kk

admin - January 12, 2009 - 8:51 am

WofOdie – great idea to have food with you to hand out. And you’re right, it is heartbreaking.

Katy – I love the idea of giving out cards, that’s so creative of you!

Margie – you’re right, it is hard because you want to help everyone but it’s not always possible to give them cash. I agree that donating money or time is a good option.

Kikibibi – I agree with you too – we have to help in some way. Thanks for your comment, it’s a good reminder!

Kristina - January 12, 2009 - 11:11 am

It’s so hard to know what to do. I think you did the right thing. I am also very cautious because you need to protect yourself and be safe first. But I always feel so guilty when I don’t give the guy at the freeway exit some change.

Annemarie - January 12, 2009 - 5:48 pm

I’d do the same as you. I don’t ever carry cash either, and I agree that some of these people are users of both substances and people, however, food is something that I can provide without those strings. It would have tortured me the same way, if she hadn’t been there in the parking lot.

ang - January 12, 2009 - 11:31 pm

I don’t know you personally, but I enjoy your blog. :) I did a search at http://scriptures.lds.org for “sick needy” and there were a bunch… this is just one: D&C 52:40 – “And remember in all things the poor and the needy, the sick and the afflicted, for he that doeth not these things, the same is not my disciple.” It’s hard, but if we are able to help when the opportunity arises, I think it’s best to try. Kudos to you for doing just that!

Alzo - January 13, 2009 - 3:51 am

This post is very thought provoking. I guess maybe a lot of us struggle with this question. The questions you raise and the thoughts others are sharing are good to think about. It has always bothered me to just walk by without helping but I think that handing out cash is not a very good solution. Offering food is a wonderful idea. Thanks to all.

admin - January 13, 2009 - 4:13 am

Hey Kristina – I know, that’s one of my biggest problems, is the fear factor. It’s hard to overlook that as a woman. Maybe it’s because my stepdad is a cop? :)

Annemarie – yeah, I’m leaning towards just having food with me at all times. It’s not a bad idea actually.

Ang – I’m glad to see you. And that’s a good scripture too, thanks for mentioning it!

Alzo- thanks for your comment. I agree – handing out food may be a great option.

Your email is never published or shared. Required fields are marked *

*

*

There was an error submitting your comment. Please try again.

CommentLuv badge
B l o g r o l l
C a t e g o r i e s
M y   B u t t o n
R e t u r n   H O M E