The Engagement Ring (Part 2)

In looking through old posts, I  realized that I told you all about our engagement story and even the wedding, but I didn’t finish telling you about the ring.  As I mentioned in the first segment, there had been quite a bit of drama surrounding my engagement ring.  Let me say up front: I’m not usually difficult or even terribly vain.  It’s just that the ring we got from the jewelers was so completely different from what we had requested, that I was a bit frustrated (that’s an understatement really).  While I laugh at it now, at the time, it was so important and so stressful.  

You see, during our first visit to the jewelers, I had given them a brochure showing the ring I wanted them to design and make for me.  It was to be a replica of the ring I had found at the Bvlgary store, a ring that I loved but that was way out of our budget.  According to the jeweler, he could make the same ring for a fraction of the cost.  So he took the pictures and he made a wax mold of the ring.  We tried it on and everything looked pretty good at that point, although it was hard to tell for sure since the wax was green which somehow detracted from the overall effect.

That was the last time I saw the ring until that wonderful day in San Francisco when the CPA asked me to marry him.  Because I had such high expectations, I was feeling rather anxious as it was to be the big “unveiling.”  Once I had gotten over the shock of the first ring (which he had thrown into the ocean), I remember opening the beautiful wood box that held my real ring.  I stared down at the shiny platinum and then my stomach sank.  While very pretty, the ring staring back at me was not at all like the ring I had shown the jeweler, the one that had teased me from the pages of the Bvlgari catalog. 

Instead, the ring my jeweler had made looked like this.  From the top of the ring, it wasn’t too bad.  Quite a bit thicker and bulkier than I wanted, but still, it was fine.

It was the side of the ring that bothered me.  There was a huge hole drilled into the metal underneath the diamond and it was very noticeable.  (You have to look hard to see it in the picture below, but it’s there.)

Also, the way the diamond was suspended made it look shallow. 

Again, it wouldn’t have been such a big deal except that we had put a lot of time and effort (and money) into this and of course we wanted it to be perfect.  After all, this was to be the ring I would be wearing for the next 50 plus years, right?  

So when we got back from our trip, I asked the jeweler why there was a hole in the ring.  He said it was for the ease of putting in the diamond.  I was a little confused.  I had never seen such a hole in any other professionally made ring so I asked if he could fix it.  He took it back and started over. 

By this time, we had made several visits to the jewelers over the course of a few months and I was getting a bit frustrated as were they, I’m sure.  The wedding was just around the corner and I was beginning to wonder if the ring I wanted was even possible.  So I told them to forget the original design and to make something simple and I’d just stick two bands on either side and call it good. 

And that’s exactly what they did.  I ended up getting a simple solitaire with two bands on either side.  The rings were finished about two days before the wedding. 

When I think back on all of the time and effort spent on this project, I laugh, because it was such a process! If I had it to do over again, I would definitely do it differently – I would just walk into a store and pick a ring from the display.  We thought we were going to save all of this money by getting a replica made of the ring I wanted.  By the time everything was said and done, it ended up costing around the same amount as the Bvlgary ring would have, if not more. 

Moral of the story: don’t stress so much over the little things.  

(Sometimes I have to learn lessons like that the hard way.) 

What about you – were you surprised with your ring or did you pick it out yourself?  Were you pleased with it?

RELATED POSTS:

The Engagement Ring

Getting Engaged, Part 6


Share/Save/Bookmark

Joanna - February 19, 2009 - 4:58 am

My husband designed my ring. It’s beautiful and I love it, but doesn’t get worn much. See, I thought I wanted a platinum ring … I didn’t realize how heavy that would be. Plus, I’m very, very clumsy. So my ring already has a few gouges in it that can’t be polished out. Which is just life, but still makes me a little sad. And now that I’ve had two kids, my fingers are no longer as slender as they were eight and a half years ago. Once my kids are a little older, I’ll see about getting it resized.

the weakonomist - February 19, 2009 - 5:01 am

I think it looks fantastic. The only ugly ring I’ve ever seen was from one my fiance’s friends. It looked terrible, and cost a lot of money. The one I got my fiance has a split shank, with small diamonds recessed in the shanks. I picked it out on my own, and then “clued” her in on it a few days later at the jewelry store. She loved it, so I knew it was the one.

Julie - February 19, 2009 - 5:15 am

Mine is/was my husband’s grandmother’s. It’s really unique. Maybe not what I would have chosen but I love it anyway. Didn’t fit though. She had itty bitty fingers. And a diamond chip on the side was missing and there was only one prong out of 4 left holding the main diamond in. So the only thing about it that I didn’t like was I was finally engaged (and we only had a 3 month engagement) and my ring was at the jeweler’s for the first few weeks. Couldn’t show it off right away.

Janet - February 19, 2009 - 6:00 am

My husband-to-be surprised me with a ring when he asked me to marry him. It was not an expensive ring by any standard but he had spent all his savings on it which meant it really was expensive in relative terms. Just a simple solitaire diamond that I would not trade for any other diamond ring in the world!

Linda - February 19, 2009 - 6:15 am

When we got engaged, we had NO $!!! He bought me a beautiful watch, and I wore it for many years. For our 25th anniversary he bought me a beautiful diamond entwined ring. Now we are headed towards our 45th anniversary, in a year and 1/2, and I keep hinting it is time for a ‘new’ bauble. I don’t think I’ll get one, but I’ll keep the old man! He is better than any ring could ever be.

The older we get, the fewer ‘things’ we want or need.

Kristy - February 19, 2009 - 6:40 am

I piked out a few rings and then let Justin made the choice. He picked my favorite. I’ve been wearing it everyday, save the last month I was expecting our first daughter, for almost ten years.

Kristy - February 19, 2009 - 6:41 am

oops–picked, not piked!

K - February 19, 2009 - 6:49 am

I have to admit – we were completely unromantic and I picked out my own ring. We are pretty pragmatic people, and my husband had never picked out any jewelry for me as gifts that I was thrilled with! : ) So I showed him a few that I liked but made it clear which one was my favorite. I would have been thrilled with any of them, but my husband did end up picking out my favorite. It is an Jaffe ring, white gold, with 1 large oval center diamond flanked by 2 smaller oval diamonds, with 3 more diamonds in the band on each side. I love it!!!

the domestic fringe - February 19, 2009 - 6:56 am

So sorry about your ring. The one they made did not look like your pict, but I love the set you ended up getting.

-FringeGirl

Jill - February 19, 2009 - 7:22 am

We had talked about getting engaged and I showed him some rings I liked. I found a business card in the console of the car from the jeweler, so I knew he’d been, but I did not know or think he’d purchased anything. So, when I got it so soon, I was surprised! My ring is a princess-cut carat solitaire, on a pretty thin white-gold band. They are perfect :)

Kelly - February 19, 2009 - 7:27 am

I’m not engaged or married yet, but I want whoever he may be to pick it out on his own. I love surprises! And I’m not that picky. All he’ll know is that I want white gold or platinum, and that he has to take my dad with him. My dad picks great jewelry! He’s also a geologist who knows how to negotiate, which means I’ll get a fabulous diamond at a great price! :)

Sue - February 19, 2009 - 7:37 am

My husband picked mine out on his own, and I absolutely love it. He was always very insistent that he would do it that way. He did know that I wanted platinum or white gold, and he asked me which shapes I liked or disliked, but that’s it. He got me a round diamond with a small square sapphire on either side, set in platinum. It’s just different enough that I’ve never seen someone with the same thing, but still classic and beautiful.
I have to say, I like your first ring, but I love the one you ended up with! And it looks great with 2 bands…a little extra sparkle never hurt anyone. :)

joy - February 19, 2009 - 8:14 am

My husband was completely clueless as to what style ring I wanted so he asked for ideas. I knew a girl who had an emerald cut diamond because she told me it made her diamond look bigger than it actually was. I had always wanted an emerald cut diamond and had expressed this to my husband. I also told him I want platinum. So I ended up getting an emerald cut diamond solitaire ring. I also told him I wanted just a plain platinum band to go with my ring, which I also got. I made it clear to him that I did not want any modifications to my ring ever. I had heard of wives getting an upgraded ring on subsequent anniversaries but I expressed I wanted my ring to always be the one I get married with. He bought it from Blue Nile and we’ve been extremely happy with it! Your rings are quite lovely and the extra sparkle is nice! :)

Mindee@ourfrontdoor - February 19, 2009 - 9:02 am

I really like what you ended up with. So many times, simple is best which is something I hope I can hammer into my girls’ heads long before it’s time to set wedding budgets!

Kristina - February 19, 2009 - 9:23 am

Your ring is gorgeous! My ring cost like $300. It’s quite small, but I’m happy with it. I may upgrade in the future, but it was what we could afford without going into debt.

admin - February 19, 2009 - 9:49 am

Joanna – that’s so sweet that your husband designed it!

Weakonomist – sounds like you did a good job picking out the ring for the sheonomost. And you’re right – I rarely see rings that are actually not pretty. They’re just all very unique-looking.

Julie – I know, there’s something about showing it off, isn’t there? I was going to NC for the wedding shower and had to spend an hour at the jewelers waiting for the ring after it was refinished because i just HAD to show it off! :)

Janet – that’s so sweet, I love that he surprised you. And a simple solitare is a great way to go!

Linda – wow, 45 years – congrats to you!! that’s amazing! And you’re probably right, the desire for the rings and such probably changes as time goes on.

Kristy – that’s a really smart way to do it, that way you both have a say in picking out the ring and you’re both happy with it.

K – ohh sounds so pretty! And don’t worry, the CPA and I weren’t romantic about it either. He learned very quickly that our tastes in jewelry were quite different!

Domestic Fringe – yeah, I’m just sorry about the headaches and the money we spent. Oh well, hindsight, right?

Jill – that’s funny that you found the card. So was it hard waiting for him to “pop the question?”

Kelly – I agree, a geologist with good taste is handy to have along! (and it sure helps to get a good deal!)

Sue – I love that he added different stones beside the diamonds. I be it’s so pretty!

Thanks Joy. I have to say that emerald cut is one of my favorite styles – it’s a classic and always looks beautiful!

Mindee – yes, I agree, simple is better. Good luck teaching that to your teenagers! :)

Kristina – good point, it’s best to stay away from getting in debt for a ring so it’s great that you didn’t. that’s one reason we had an established budget – we definitely didn’t want to go into debt over it!

Sarah - February 19, 2009 - 9:59 am

My husband and I went ring shopping together. It was never important to me that I knew EXACTLY what it looked like beforehand, but I did want to like it, so I made sure that he knew what I liked and then left the ultimate choice up to him. The only stipulation was that it had to include sapphires because my mother’s engagement ring was a sapphire.

The ring he picked was a surprise, then, and I *love* it.

Jenna @ Newlyweds - February 19, 2009 - 10:28 am

The ring is gorgeous. We actually had our rings made also, and yes it is quite the process. I have learned through it though that I like things a certain way, never knew that about myself before. But I am very happy with the end result.

Jenny - February 19, 2009 - 10:33 am

I picked out the ring I wanted, but they had to special order it in yellow gold (even though white gold and platinum are in style, I’ve always liked yellow gold b/c I think they make the diamonds stand out more).

It turned out the store wasn’t able to get the ring I wanted in yellow gold. So Dave had to make a big decision on his own — get the ring I picked out in white gold, or find a similar one in yellow gold. He ended finding a similar one. The band was thicker than I would have preferred, so I ended up getting a thinner wedding band. But I still liked it…I never would have exchanged it.

In the end, it really grew on me and now I love it and wouldn’t trade it for anything.

The Wife of Odie - February 19, 2009 - 10:38 am

Oh I remember the drama of the rings! But I’m so glad you have the ring you do. It looks great!!!

Millie - February 19, 2009 - 10:50 am

The only thing I told my husband before we got engaged was the size and shape of the diamond I wanted. Other than that, I left it all up to him. He did an amazing job, and I’m so very proud of him for it =) It’s very unique, which I love, but I think that gives it a kind of “love it or hate it” kind of feel. Luckily, I LOVE it, not only because nobody else has anything remotely like it, but because Josh designed it himself, especially for me.

BTW, he proposed on the beach in Half Moon Bay, isn’t that where you got engaged too??

admin - February 19, 2009 - 11:09 am

Sarah – so cool that you have sapphires just like your mom’s!

Jenna – hey, you used a jewelers too? Would you use one again? I’m not sure I would after our experience. Hmm… maybe

Jenny – sounds like he made the write choice and I’m glad it worked out too!

WofO – ha, I know, it was quite the experience! I’m just glad you were there for me to ask advice. :)

Millie – I agree, unique is good! And yes, Half Moon Bay – what a small world! Where did he propose while you were there?

Robynn's Ravings - February 19, 2009 - 11:18 am

THAT is a LOVELY ring set on your hand and it looks absolutely beautiful on you. Glad it worked out in the end but what a headache.

I have a horrendous ring story and I’ll be writing about it on my blog!

Eryn - February 19, 2009 - 11:22 am

I picked out my ring, and I love it. There aren’t a lot of carats or anything, but it is perfect for me!!

Melody C. - February 19, 2009 - 12:26 pm

My first ring was designed by my first husband and a close friend. It was a large oval ruby with a small diamond on either side. I loved that ring and will do something special with the ruby. My second husband doesn’t have a clue about jewelry and was relieved for me to create one with a goldsmith. I have a wide white gold band with a yellow gold wire embedded and the two diamonds set to make a “top”. I’d like something different in the future, maybe get an anniversary set with some more flash!

Isabelle - February 19, 2009 - 12:47 pm

I got my ring some years after the proposal – nothing particular though because engagement rings are not/ were not the big tradition here in Europe. We had always decided to buy the ring on a trip to Anvers, as it is the worlds biggest diamond center. In the end we found one in the last shop and last minute – as I was looking for a tension ring. Anyway, we were lucking to be able to buy the ring all together, because earlier that day I was hit by a piece of a railway bridge falling down, fortunately only hitting me slightly on the arm; a few inches to the side and I would have been killed by it.
By now the ring has a lot of dents and scratches but it will be my wedding band when we will ever decide to finally have the wedding. In fact I am already commemorating on the “speech” that I want the priest to do over the ring ….

erin - February 19, 2009 - 1:04 pm

This makes me laugh, because we (I) had such stress about my engagement ring. DH wanted to pick it out, but he was insistent on yellow gold, which I HATE. And I just didn’t trust him to pick out the one thing I would wear every day for the next 50+ years. I knew I would love whatever he picked, but I didn’t want to ever see another woman’s ring and think, How beautiful, I wish… . I ended up finding a four different rings I liked and printed out the pictures, handed them to DH, and said, Pick one and surprise me. He picked my favorite, a 1/3 ct. round diamond set in white gold with small diamonds channel-set on either side. It had a matching band and funny, when he proposed to me, he did not take the band out of the box! So I got engaged with “two” rings. :)

We were pretty poor when we got engaged and he was always a little disappointed in my ring, because it isn’t a huge diamond and it isn’t super fancy, but I love it. For our second anniversary he got me a new larger center stone. I have never seen another ring that I like better than mine. Lots of gorgeous ones, but my engagement/wedding rings are so perfect for me and I still love them as much as the day he put them on my finger. (And him, of course!)

admin - February 19, 2009 - 1:39 pm

Robyn – why thank you, and I can’t wait to read your story!

Erin – that’s okay, there doesn’t have to be a lot of carats for it to be beautiful and special.

Melody – your ring sounds so pretty! And I agree – you definitely need to do something nice with the ruby since they’re such beautiful stones.

Isabelle – scary, I’m glad you weren’t seriously hurt! And btw – I love tension rings, I think they’re so pretty!

Erin, sweet story! I love that your husband wanted to pick it out and that you’re so happy with it – that’s what truly matters.

Heather - February 20, 2009 - 12:11 am

My fiance and I designed my engagement ring together. At first, I was confused & frustrated about why he wanted my involvement, since he knows my style perfectly and I wanted to be surprised. But I trusted him, and he was right to push me to do things the way we did. We found a jeweler in Chicago who specializes in custom designing rings (at affordable prices), and the three of us designed it together, scribbling pictures on scratch paper. My fiance is an artist, so having a creative process involved really spoke to him & made it special for him. I LOVE the symbolism it has- how it has parts of both of us working together in it.

Also, I am a nurse, so we had it made specifically so I can safely & comfortably wear it to work. I know 3-4 nurses who have lost their diamonds when taking off their latex gloves, so I got a round diamond w/ a 6 prong setting, and then we rotated the position of the prongs so the outermost two were on the left & right, rather than top & bottom. Also, the center stone is nice & low to my finger, so it won’t get caught in my gloves, and the side stones are double bead set to be more secure, but still look very dainty.

One of the things I love about my ring is that as soon as I show it to another friend or family member, of course they admire it, & then they say, “That is so YOU!”

Heidi - February 20, 2009 - 2:05 pm

Tabitha,

Ey! When I saw this post was about RINGS, I shuddered. Just the thought of talking about RINGS makes me uncomfortable. (I know too many women who are so wrapped up in The Ring, that I instantly tune them out at the sound of the word, “carat.”

Your story, simply told, was honest and sweet. You don’t use sarcastic/mean spirited language when you write – even when it’s about something you are (or were) uber pissed about. You just explain it in the nicest terms, which is what I like about you! You seem even-keeled, and reading your blog keeps me even-keeled.

I love that you think differently about THE RING now. I find it inspiring when people’s perspectives on a situation change. I found your perspective on the ring refreshing.

And, Linda’s comment warmed my heart. 45 years! Congrats Linda!

As for my ring, it was Joe’s great-grandmothers. It didn’t need to be re-sized or (in the tradition of high school senior rings) wrapped in yarn so it wouldn’t fall off. It’s the prettiest antique ring I’ve ever seen and every time I look at it I think of his great-grandmother, who lived in a three-story walk-up in Brooklyn and helped raise his mother.

When he proposed to me at our housewarming party this November, I had no idea what was coming and no idea I was getting this woman’s ring.

Every time I look at it, I think of her. Every time I do something modern (like type a narcissistic TWITTER update) I think of her. Every time I use fancy lotion on my hands, I think of her.

I’ve taken it off only once since November – to make meat patties. Meat patties are disgusting and I thought his great-grandmother, wherever she is, would appreciate the gesture.

Alzo - February 21, 2009 - 8:51 pm

Interesting story. That first ring must have made you so frustrated that you were ready to throw it into the ocean. I like what you ended up with.

KelliSue - March 19, 2009 - 5:48 am

My husband proposed to me with a beautiful 2 carat platinum over silver diamonique ring from QVC. I picked it out. You see, we were both abandoned by our first spouses, and left us with 2 mortgages, 2 car loans, and 2 little children. That made 4 little children, 7 and under. Two years later we had 5 little children, 9 and under, had paid off the car loans,bought a larger home, paid off all of our residual debt, and had great peace. Grandma gave me her 1 carat square cut wedding set that Grandpa gave her in 1942. I wear that proudly, and my faux diamond ring set is in a box in my bureau. Every so often one of my little girls pulls it out and asks about it. That’s the ring Papa gave me when he asked me to marry him. They squeal, and remark how pretty it is. When they’re older, they’ll also understand about priorities, and avoiding debt, and choosing a wonderful husband over and above what he can buy at the time. It’s a precious thing to me, that little box in my drawer. And I too think of Grandma Collins and my dear Grandpa everytime I wash my hands, put laundry in the washer, and so on.

http://www.kellikolz.blogspot.com

Rick - May 6, 2009 - 7:03 am

Sorry that you had a bad experience. Although I don’t know the jeweler, they probably thought that you’d just settle for what they thought looked similar.

Rick´s last blog post.."What is palladium?" – a question that really needs to be clarified.

Kate - May 21, 2009 - 7:22 am

My husband proposed when I was still in college. It was a HUGE shock, and a HUGE surprise. Needless to say, I thought I still had another year or so before I had to start thinking about THE RING. But, as is generally the case with him, he had the perfect proposal and the perfect ring. It is chunky and modern and everything I would have picked out myself. In fact, it’s probably BETTER than I would have picked out myself, since I’m sure I would have stressed over the decision and tried on a million.

The best part? A very close friend’s father designed it and made it for me. And Benjamin got to help design it, so it is one-of-a-kind. What a man, huh?

Kate´s last blog post..He Says… Schnitzel as Nana

Pareja - June 30, 2009 - 5:35 pm

Your post was very interesting when I found it over google on Wednesday by my search for anvers shopping. I have your blog now in my bookmarks and I visit your blog again, soon. Take care. Parejaspareja.es

Elnora Lamon - November 27, 2009 - 3:30 pm

Hi, I have accidently come across your site whilst browsing around Google as I am looking for some information on art deco engagement rings!. It’s a very interesting blog so I have bookmarked you and intend to return tomorrow to have a proper look when I can give it more time.

Lisa - April 18, 2010 - 3:19 pm

Oh my gosh, your experience seems IDENTICAL to mine! I fell in love with a beautiful split shank ring that was WAY out of our budget, but my local jewelry swore he could replicate it for half the cost. A couple months and a pretty penny later, I ended up with a so, so ring that looked nothing like the original. I wore the ring for 2 years, but was never happy with it. Last week, I was able to sell the ring and now I’m in the process of buying a new one. This time, I’m choosing something that’s already made – Something I can look at on my hand and say, “Yes, I love this.”

Jillian Erhart - September 5, 2010 - 4:13 am

I greatly loved reading your post! I love all things antiques, but in particular engagement rings.

Your email is never published or shared. Required fields are marked *

*

*

There was an error submitting your comment. Please try again.

CommentLuv badge
B l o g r o l l
C a t e g o r i e s
M y   B u t t o n
R e t u r n   H O M E