Marriage – Friends with Exes

A recent post by my Internet friend Jill got me thinking about the age-old question:  can you be friends with your ex?  Actually, I began thinking about this long before her post.  In fact, I can remember a conversation that the CPA and I had before we got married.  A conversation that included me saying (in rather strong language) that it was absolutely not okay for us to communicate on a regular basis with ex girlfriends/boyfriends.  Ever.

Fast forward a year and a half and you’ll find us happily married.  Of course you’ll also find us on Facebook, the social network that prides itself on reconnecting people from your past, people like ex boyfriends or girlfriends.

We had been on Facebook for about six months before I received my first “friend request” from one of my exes.  Now this particular ex was not someone that my husband was fond of (if a spouse could ever really be fond of an ex).  It had something to do with how recently we had dated and how our relationship had ended.  Because of this, when I received the request I was hesitant to respond.  So I brought the question to my husband.  I told him that I would gladly leave it alone and not answer if he preferred because I knew that  I could easily walk away and not look back.  I admit that there was a part of me that was curious, of course.  Had the ex married well, was he happy?  That sort of thing.  Then there’s the other part, the petty part, that wanted him to see that I was happy and that I survived life after him.  But either way, I wouldn’t respond if the CPA was at all uncomfortable.

I should have known better.  The CPA said he wasn’t bothered in the least and to go ahead.  So I did — I said “hello, how are you.”  He said, “I’m fine.  How are you?  I see you’re married?  Congratulations.”  And that was that.  End of story.

Since that time, I’ve been in touch with at least three or four other exes, a couple of whom I had dated seriously and the others not so seriously.  What I have found, for me at least, is that being friends with exes is okay, within reason and with certain caveats.  Mainly, that the communications aren’t frequent or too personal, that the intentions behind them are pure, and that it’s not done in secret.  In my mind, if those conditions are met, then it’s not really a problem.

What about you?  Are you comfortable with your spouse communicating with exes or is it definitely off-limits?

Share/Save/Bookmark

Julie - April 14, 2009 - 4:24 am

We’re both friends with exes on Facebook. But we only communicate with them once or twice a year. Neither one of us are a big fan of the other one’s exes so we try not to communicate with them too often. We do however understand that they were big parts of our lives in the past so we are naturally going to want to know how they are doing once in awhile.

Julie´s last blog post..Good News!!!

Gracia - April 14, 2009 - 5:38 am

I dated a guy for almost 4 years, then broke up for 2 years and then started dating my partner. But the ex is still one of my best friends. How do we manage? I really don’t know!

Gracia´s last blog post..When life gets in your way

Rachel - April 14, 2009 - 5:59 am

I don’t think either of us really likes the idea. I can totally agree with you, though, when you talk about “the petty part.” I had a rather long relationship before I met my husband and it ended badly. Part of me wishes the ex could see that I’m not the same person anymore. I’ve been successful and I have a wonderful husband and family. I guess it is silly, really, but we’re human!

Any time I think of becoming “friends” with someone on facebook that I dated or even someone I crushed in high school, as innocent as it may be, I always think of how I would feel if he became “friends” with one of the girls he dated. It just doesn’t sit well with me, so I avoid it all together.

Rachel´s last blog post..Menu in the Works

Kate - April 14, 2009 - 6:10 am

My husband’s high school sweetheart (aka EX) was actually the link that made us meet! Although once in awhile things get a little too personal (they will reminisce about high school prom or something like that), in general I think it is so sweet that they are so close. Their relationship doesn’t bother me, especially since I was friends with her before I ever met my husband anyway. But maybe it helps that she is happily married too and they are one of our closest “couple friends”.

However, I feel like there is often ONE ex that you could never be friends with. For me, it’s the guy who I dated in the time that my husband and I broke up while we were dating. I can see why he doesn’t like him :) And the same goes for my husband… there’s one ex of his that I really don’t like hearing about. We recently got invited to her wedding, and I was nervous about how my husband would react. We are happily married, but I didn’t want him to want to go! Thankfully, he didn’t, and I didn’t even have to express my uncomfortable feelings.

Kate´s last blog post..He Says… Thank you, Gosselins

emilyG - April 14, 2009 - 6:10 am

Well. Sigh. Here goes.

Me and the Piping Designer (haha, first time I referred to him that way) are okay with most exes. The ones we’re a little iffy about are the ones we were with while we met each other. Haha. Both relationships were falling apart, and we found ourselves together when it was all said and done. The way I see it, we gave each other courage to end our toxic relationships for good.

Anyhow, it’ll only have been two years this summer. So it’s all a little fresh. Maybe with time, it wouldn’t be a big deal to talk to those exes. Although, I think I’m the only one who has any interest in it, because I was actually a friend with mine first, and he says he has no desire to ever talk to her again.

Shrug. :)

emilyG´s last blog post..Introducing: Ella in Houston.

Jill - April 14, 2009 - 6:19 am

When I saw your post come up in my reader, I thought “Yay!” I was really excited to see what you had to say! I agree with your sentiments, not too frequent and not secretive. Aside from my husband, I’ve not been in many serious relationships anyway, so thankfully that eliminates some of the problem right there!

Jill´s last blog post..Fashion Friday: 2nd Edition

Joanna - April 14, 2009 - 6:23 am

I’m okay with Facebook friending because it’s about as superficial a “friendship” as you can get. Other than FB, neither of us is in contact with our exes. If it happened, like you said, a lot would depend on the situation. We’ve both moved far, far away from our childhood homes so the issue hasn’t come up. We’ve been together for nearly fourteen years so maybe it wouldn’t bother either of us at all.

Joanna´s last blog post..Mess

The Wife of Odie - April 14, 2009 - 6:23 am

I have no problem being friends with exes, but don’t really find much of a desire to do so and it seems to work out nicely that way.

The Wife of Odie´s last blog post..thailand = vacation

joy - April 14, 2009 - 7:03 am

Personally, I’ll be honest and say I have a morbid curiosity about my ex. I’m not a stalker or what have you but I guess I just wonder what happened to him. I know he is married and has two children I think. I wouldn’t mind being FB friends with him but for some reason I don’t think he feels the same way. I have no idea why since he was the one who broke up with me. I did contact him once a long time ago before I got married but it was a brief and curt response. Oh well. Now, I don’t think my husband would like if I was FB friends with my ex because he knows how much emotional pain my ex caused me. But I say let bygones be bygones. We’re both older and have our own lives. However, we were once the center of each other’s lives. My feelings on my husband being FB friends with an ex, well I don’t know how to answer this one. I know there were girls he really liked and dated but there wasn’t one person who ever held the GF spot. Honestly I’d be a little jealous. My husband is a great guy, loving, kind, sweet, etc and I’m glad no one figured it out before I did. :)

emilyG - April 14, 2009 - 7:04 am

Oh, and I read your friend Jill’s blog entry. And yes, I think it’s way out of line to talk to someone of the opposite sex for hours in the middle of the night, if you OR they are married. Crazies.

emilyG´s last blog post..Introducing: Ella in Houston.

Mindee@ourfrontdoor - April 14, 2009 - 7:46 am

We have a policy of not “friending” anyone we’ve had past relationships with. One of us has some deep seated insecurities on this issue and so we both keep this policy to avoid misunderstandings and upset.
There have been e-mail communications from exes from time to time. The policy there is to keep it short and friendly and to share all e-mails (through blind cc) with the spouse.
Marriage is precious and needs protection.

Mindee@ourfrontdoor´s last blog post..The Horse Earns Her Keep

Kristina - April 14, 2009 - 8:27 am

Honestly, this hasn’t come up a lot for me. Neither one of us dated a lot of people before we got married, but there is one guy in particular my husband doesn’t like, but he doesn’t necessarily have a problem with me having contact with him.

Sarah @ BecomingSarah.com - April 14, 2009 - 8:42 am

Donald and I are both extremists on this point. No exes. No former love interests or crushes. No “friendships” with members of the opposite sex. No exceptions. The end.

Sarah @ BecomingSarah.com´s last blog post..27 Weeks: Still.

Terra - April 14, 2009 - 8:51 am

I think there’s just a fine line in the communication… to be friendly and civil is one thing, for them to be communicating on a daily basis and meeting up is another. I don’t see anything wrong with it for the most part IF the spouse knows about it and feels okay about it. :)

Eryn - April 14, 2009 - 9:52 am

I definitely think if there is an ongoing communication or even a friendship, that is not healthy or right. But the occasional “how have you been” (as happens often on facebook) is harmless. :)

Eryn´s last blog post..12 weeks

Robynn's Ravings - April 14, 2009 - 9:58 am

There certainly is a strong draw, especially if they were horrid to you or something, to want to say “See? Look how well I’m doing.”

Robynn’s Ravings´s last blog post..Meet the Dog Mother and Maker of the Cake!

erin - April 14, 2009 - 10:00 am

A couple very un-serious exes from high school are friends on Facebook. I don’t talk with them hardly at all… as someone else mentioned, it really is such a superficial relationship. But – a serious ex “friended” me last week. It’s still just sitting there and I doubt I’ll do anything with it, neither accept nor ignore. DH wouldn’t like it if I accepted. I doubt I’d like it if he accepted from a serious ex either, but he’s not on FB. We don’t try to be friends with serious exes… that part of our lives is over.

erin´s last blog post..even more soap pictures

Courtney - April 14, 2009 - 10:06 am

Even though I’m not married, I was recently thinking about this topic also. I was recently in a relationship, and although it was not a long one it was a serious one. Everything just “fell into place” and seemed to just “fit” and felt right, so it moved quickly. This guy became a best friend fast, he was the first person I wanted to share things with and who I would call just because. But that’s gone now. Maybe it’s for the better, the jury is still out. And although he would like to continue with a friendship I don’t know if I can. I don’t know if I can because it would be too hard to draw the line, and I’m bad with setting boundaries and sticking to them. And I don’t know if it’s a good thing… “Honey, this is my ex-bf/current friend So And So whom I was very close with and discussed marriage with and was willing to move over 3,000 miles to be closer to.” It’s probably not the most appropriate friendship, and I’m kinda at a fork in the road: be just friends that talk on a semi regular basis or cut it off completely. I don’t know. Now I feel like I’m rambling. Anyone understand what I’m saying, where I’m coming from, have any advice?

Courtney´s last blog post..Picture of the Day 103

the domestic fringe - April 14, 2009 - 10:23 am

Interesting question. We too have ‘friends’ on facebook, etc. that are exes (boyfriend & girlfriend variety) and all is ok. No big deal really, just an email now and then.

I do know a family where the ‘new’ wife is friends with the ex-wife and they all go to church and sit together. Interesting concept to me. I wouldn’t, couldn’t do it.

-FringeGirl

the domestic fringe´s last blog post..Like Father, Like Son

Jess - April 14, 2009 - 10:27 am

I think it depends on the ex. While I’m madly in love with my husband-to-be, there are some past exes that I’ve hurt or hurt me, and I don’t think it’d be right to friend them, mostly because if that bad past is there, what’s the point? And there’s really not much of a point in working through things… for what, a friendship with someone I dated for 4 years?

I think there is a difference between someone you dated 1-2x, versus someone you had a long relationship with. The 1-2x turned into friendships rather than relationships, and I wouldn’t classify them as exes. I do make a point of letting the husband-to-be know about them, just so he doens’t find out about them some point in the future and wonders why I didn’t tell him.

Openness between you and your significant other seems to be key. And, if the man-to-be had a problem with any of these, of course, I’d respect his feelings rather than my facebook friends.

Jess´s last blog post..Invitations, RSVPs, and Food

Blond Duck - April 14, 2009 - 11:44 am

Popped in to say hi! Love your site!

Personally, I avoid all exes just out of personal preference. But I see nothing wrong with being polite.

Blond Duck´s last blog post..Ode to Halibut and How I Love Thee

Melody C. - April 14, 2009 - 12:48 pm

I’ll speak up and be the odd voice out. Mr. and I both have ex-spouses, mine of 17 years, his of 10. We will both talk on the phone to our respective exs within earshot of each other. I know the names (and too much information!) about girlfriends dating back to middle school. I think growing up with divorced parents who both came to school functions, graduations, weddings, etc. set a great example of how past spouses can remain friendly without threatening a current relationship. And communication is key. My ex can chat on FB with female friends and reminisce about old times. I know where he is, and I know where he wants to be. That means everything to me! Best part – when the tables are turned, he lets me chat with male friends because he knows where I want to be.

Jenna @ Newlyweds - April 14, 2009 - 2:31 pm

I have a couple of exes on facebook, none too serious, and I don’t think my hubby knows about it. Not that I kept it from him, but just not a big deal. Now if it was one of my major exes, he would not like it, and I wouldn’t.

Luckily for me my hubby does not do the computer so I don’t worry about these things with him.

Jenna @ Newlyweds´s last blog post..Sloppy Joes and Corn Fritters

Cody - April 14, 2009 - 2:46 pm

We’ve been together since we were 15 and 16, so there really are no “exes” to speak of… so, I don’t know how I would feel about it.

Cody´s last blog post..Frederik Meijer Gardens

Ali @ Kent Chronicles - April 14, 2009 - 4:27 pm

I have no worries being kind – saying hello, etc – to an ex. I really can’t avoid the ones I still go to church with, or see at my old office once in awhile, so why not say hello? It seems to be they that have more problem with it than me.

Hubby doesn’t get a say – I have to put up with his *$##!! ex-wife on a regular basis, so deal with it ;-) .

Ali @ Kent Chronicles´s last blog post..Homeschool #016 – Can’t see the Trees for the Forest

Briony - April 14, 2009 - 8:54 pm

i don’t have a spouse but i don’t really like the idea of being friends with exes. first i think that it is important to recognize the difference between a friend and an acquaintance. I don’t think it is wrong to be polite to an ex, but I think there needs to be boundaries because most often that person has had a small piece of you emotionally at one point and it is too easy for humans to be attracted to the comfort.

so i wouldn’t say that i am friends with any of my exes but i am friendly towards them, we are in good standing but it isn’t a place that requires any kind of investment on either persons part.

I may be wrong in this area, I may change my mind in the future but this is how i feel at this point in my life.

Briony´s last blog post..the first step

Heather @ alis grave nil - April 15, 2009 - 1:42 pm

I think it so depends on the situation. Right? I don’t know. I would like to say I’m cool with it, but some situations are just sooo… um… complex? I guess I’m not quite as awesome about stuff like that. I’ll admit it. I get jealous. It’s not that I don’t trust my husband, but I wouldn’t want to put us into a situation where I might start acting like a lunatic… if he was friends with some of those people, let’s say, on FB or something, I would probably freak out about little stuff. I’m just crazy.

Heather @ alis grave nil´s last blog post..Nine years ago today

V. Higgins - April 16, 2009 - 9:12 am

I had never been in a serious relationship before my husband so that side is pretty easy! :-P My husband had one serious girlfriend who he broke up with about 2-3 months before we got together. But they had been been best friends for years. They had always stayed in contact so at first I didn’t have much of an option and it was uncomfortable since we were still getting our footing. Eventually though it all worked out and I am Facebook friends with her, we also have dinner/hang out when we’re down south or when she comes up north. I have a lot of fun with her and probably have more conversations with her than hubby does. :-P

Carissa - April 17, 2009 - 8:47 am

Oh lord — I am one of those freaks that stays friendes with her ex’s, sets them up with their now wife (except one), attends their weddings and sends their new babies gifts! I am harassed about this by so many of my friends BUT really it is nice. I actually have benifited (sp?) from the friendships and don’t have to lose someone who was a good friend as well! (I did let one guy go when his then girlfriend now wife was uncomfortable with our friendship so I am not completely crazy and if Aaron ever had an issue I would stop as well…)

Carissa´s last blog post..Winners

Nan - April 18, 2009 - 11:23 pm

I think the key is openness and comfortableness all around. Polite acquaintance works for us. It also helped that the first 5 years of our relationship were pre-facebook/myspace, so we had space to settle in before the exes reappeared.

There is one exception though. The guy I dated right before meeting my husband is my brother’s best friend. In fact, our families have known each other for 30 years. So while we still here news of him (and his wife) from my mom or brother, most of the awkwardness is gone. (it probably helps that I’m not in touch with any of them any longer, it’s all news from mom and brother.)

Like someone above says, I know where I want to be and I know where my husband wants to be. And we’re open about hearing from anyone from our past.

Arthurdent - December 9, 2009 - 6:49 pm

Wow, except for a few of you, you all seem really insecure in your relationships. You will think I’m wrong, and try to justify it, but the reality is, if you were secure, you’d have no reason to have an issue with someone remaining friends with an ex. Why get married to someone if the level of trust is so low?

And to the woman who said she and her husband don’t even have friends of the opposite sex, that is just downright dysfunctional. Seriously.

ABS - February 11, 2010 - 1:50 am

It’s not for anyone else to judge what is functional or dysfunctional in a marriage. Even a qualified psychiatrist or psychologist would not condescend to judge that.

Communication matters. If you are a jealous freak with trust issues maybe you had a rough childhood. If you have a no jealousy and are best friends with your partners serious exes then maybe you are too accepting and acting like a doormat. Or maybe if you are not friends with exes you and protecting your relationship in the best way you see fit. Maybe if you have exes over for tea you are just a really well adjusted person who had a great family life when you were younger, or maybe it’s just a very low concern on your priority list.

As you can see, looking at someone’s actions and choices tells you no information about their motivations, mental health, or level of functionality in their relationship.

The only way for any functionality is not to assume that jealousy doesn’t exist if it does, but to talk about it. If you make compromises or put your relationship at a higher priority than your friendships then it should be mutually agreed upon.

At the end of the day you have to realise that you can’t control what the other person does, thinks or feels. But you can control how much you tell your partner about what you do, think and feel, and hopefully you’ve chosen someone who consents to and participates in the same level of openness that you do.

There’s no right answer to the question except this: communicate.

Your email is never published or shared. Required fields are marked *

*

*

There was an error submitting your comment. Please try again.

CommentLuv badge
B l o g r o l l
C a t e g o r i e s
M y   B u t t o n
R e t u r n   H O M E